Dialogue on pheromones: Avery Gilbert / James V. Kohl
This is a link to my comments on Avery Gilbert’s opinion of Richard L. Doty’s book: “The Great Pheromone Myth.”
I’ve edited and reproduced my comments here with an indicator of the point I was trying to address:
1. Some people may believe that the evidence for priming pheromones in mammals is weak and artifactual.
The required levels of biological organization (i.e., gene-cell-tissue-organ-organ system) have been detailed. So has the evolved neurophysiological mechanism that links mammalian pheromones to their priming effect on hormones. The evidence is not weak, it’s overwhelming!
2. Dr. Doty stretches the definition of pheromone to include or exclude his qualifiers.
I do not advocate stretching the original definition of pheromones. They are social odors and they release definite behaviors. The definite behaviors exist because of the developmental (hormone-driven) processes the pheromones effect.
3. Dr. Doty limits the definition of pheromone to include or exclude his qualifiers.
I do not advocate limiting the original definition. There is no science from any species that indicates that the concept infers (as Doty does on page 3) “…that a plurality of mammalian behaviors and endocrine responses is uniquely determined in an invariant way by single or small sets of chemical stimuli….”
4. Experiments with male mice show that application of Chanel No. 5 causes him to prefer to mate with Chanel No. 5 scented females. That makes Chanel No. 5 a pheromone.
The male mouse (or the males and females of any species) must first have been genetically predisposed to respond (or not) to the epigenetic influence (on hormones) of a mother’s pheromones. Otherwise no animal could be conditioned to respond to the initial association of a mother’s pheromones with the odor of a perfume.
5. General comments on alternative beliefs about sex pheromones, which include (A) no chemical qualifies as a human sex pheromone (B) many chemicals qualify as human pheromones (C) human sex pheromones do not exist.
Maternal pheromones can be considered sex pheromones because females produce more of the hormones that metabolize to the pheromones of females than do males (and vice versa). These sex pheromones also are processed by a sexually differentiated olfactory system, which allows them to have a different effect on the hormones of males than on the hormones of females, and the effect on hormones is what causes the behavioral affects.
The sexual dimorphism is the main reason to keep the concept of sex pheromones, as they are central to the development of sexual preferences. Food odors, for comparison, are central to the development of food preferences, but there is no sexual dimorphism in the food odors or in their effect on the hormones of males and females, or in how those hormones affect behavior.
If we eliminate the concept of sex pheromones, there is no biologically based explanation for the development of either typical or atypical mammalian sexual preferences (and associated behaviors that are sometimes manifest). Doty’s attempt to disprove the existence of mammalian pheromones, which include mammalian sex pheromones, is akin to me attempting to prove that food odors don’t exist. After all, no single or small sets of food odor uniquely determine in an invariant way the plurality of mammalian behaviors and endocrine responses associated with the development of food preferences.
The rest of the story will become much clearer in the next few months as the eusocial insect model of olfactory/pheromonal influences is extended to mammals, including humans.
Want more on the same topic?
Swipe/Drag Left and Right To Browse Related Posts:
Biophotonically charged life (9)
2 MIN READ
0
Impeaching the God of Abraham (8)
4 MIN READ
0
Abiogenesis vs microRNA biogenesis (3)
3 MIN READ
0
From quantum physics to quantum souls (4)
8 MIN READ
0
The tipping point (revisted): 69,000 publications
4 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent base editing and correction of mutations (1)
3 MIN READ
0
Light-activated error-free DNA repair (4)
3 MIN READ
0
The next reformation: 500 years too late? (1)
< 1 MIN READ
0
The next reformation: 500 years too late? (2)
2 MIN READ
0
Virulence: Out of stock
2 MIN READ
0
Faith in evolution: Paleontology as a molecular science
5 MIN READ
0
Until death: Virus-driven failure of multisensory integration (3)
4 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent structure and function: Until death (3)
3 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent structure and function: Until death (2)
5 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent structure and function: Until death (1)
4 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent physical and biophysical constraints (7)
2 MIN READ
0
Where do sex differences come from?
< 1 MIN READ
0
Dobzhansky 1973 and precision medicine (5)
3 MIN READ
0
Science journalists or paid propagandists? (4)
6 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent de novo creation and neurogenesis (2)
5 MIN READ
0
Survivors of RNA-mediated terrorism
5 MIN READ
0
Polycombic ecological adaptation as a science, not a theory (2)
12 MIN READ
0
Hypothesis free pseudoscience vs facts (5)
6 MIN READ
0
Hydrogen-atom energy in DNA base pairs
6 MIN READ
0
Conserved biophotonic emissions
7 MIN READ
2
Biophysically constrained cell type differentiation
3 MIN READ
0
The Mind’s Eyes (revisited)
10 MIN READ
0
Cracking the Olfactory Code?
5 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent RNA methylation (6)
9 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated physics, chemistry, and molecular epigenetics (5)
6 MIN READ
0
Magic, Miracle, or Molecular Mechanism?
10 MIN READ
0
Nutrient-dependent life vs virus-driven pathology
4 MIN READ
0
Soil bacteria, bulls, cows, microRNAs, and mammary glands (2)
3 MIN READ
0
Juvenile hormone links atoms to ecosystems
3 MIN READ
0
Genes, orchid odors, and pheromones from blonds
5 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated everything
4 MIN READ
0
Gene creation (revisited)
2 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated terms of virus-induced en-deer-ment
2 MIN READ
0
“New” epigenetic mechanism for lifelong learning?
3 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated development (2)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Ignoring top-down causation
2 MIN READ
0
A special issue on nutritional epigenetics
5 MIN READ
0
Methylation maintains cell type differences
3 MIN READ
0
Quantum correlations/pseudoscience
3 MIN READ
0
Questions about life’s diversity
21 MIN READ
0
From Hydra to humans vs a Lakatosian research program
4 MIN READ
0
The future of physics predicts no future for evolutionary theory
3 MIN READ
0
Sackler Colloquium: Effects or AFFECTS on Behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Eliminating correlations from evolutionary ecology
6 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated species specificity
2 MIN READ
0
Sexual differentiation of cell types in plants
2 MIN READ
0
A model of MHC 'evolution'
2 MIN READ
0
No understanding of biodiversity
2 MIN READ
0
2014 and 2004 Nobel Prize in Medicine
3 MIN READ
0
Did our adapted mind evolve? (Revisited)
2 MIN READ
0
RNA-directed DNA methylation and RNA-mediated events
5 MIN READ
1
Quantum physics meets Evolutionary Psychology News
2 MIN READ
0
Watching and waiting for more retractions
2 MIN READ
0
Behavior (3): All responses are RNA-mediated in bees
3 MIN READ
0
Behavior (2): All responses are RNA-mediated not genetically-determined
4 MIN READ
0
Evolutionary heritage or ecological adaptation? Racism versus reality
4 MIN READ
0
Epimutations: Attacking pseudoscientific dogmas
4 MIN READ
0
Order and disorder: Ecological adaptations not mutations
6 MIN READ
0
Drunks and Monkeys: Pseudoscientific nonsense
2 MIN READ
0
Ecologically linked adapted ants and brains
2 MIN READ
0
96 fixed amino acid substitutions, not 96 genes
6 MIN READ
0
Social experiences epigenetically effect gene networks
2 MIN READ
0
Understanding the role of mutations and evolution
4 MIN READ
0
Evolution: innovations may have non-adaptive origins (sans mutations)
2 MIN READ
0
Are pheromones responsible for human body odour assessment?
2 MIN READ
0
Nutrient-dependent / pheromone-controlled social structure
2 MIN READ
0
Random mutations: nothing adaptive in 3 billion years
< 1 MIN READ
0
Hormones effect sensitivity to androsterone
2 MIN READ
0
Evolved development of olfactory systems
2 MIN READ
0
A “new” view of evolution sans mutations
< 1 MIN READ
0
Epigenetics and metabolism converge with pheromone production
2 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic maintenance of transcription / neuronal migration
2 MIN READ
0
Epigenetics and evolutionary success
< 1 MIN READ
0
Non-random evolution of a “molecular handshake”
2 MIN READ
0
Adaptive evolution: Genetic selection against some disorders
3 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects underlie sexual preferences IV
< 1 MIN READ
0
Music to our ears and song in birds: a common sense approach
2 MIN READ
0
Thinking about what we know (or not)
2 MIN READ
0
A mathematical model of phenotypic cause, effects on genes, and affects on behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Functional vomeronasal receptor genes in primates?
2 MIN READ
0
Non random adaptive evolution
< 1 MIN READ
0
Fish Odor Syndrome
< 1 MIN READ
0
Is there a model for that?
3 MIN READ
0
One of the clearest examples of epigenetic effects
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromone-induced learning: a NEW model?
2 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects underlie sexual preferences (duh, and food preferences)
2 MIN READ
0
The genetics myth meets the great pheromone myth
2 MIN READ
0
A key mutational event? More story-telling. Olfaction modulates vision.
4 MIN READ
0
A key mutational event? That’s not very likely.
3 MIN READ
0
Mutated genes and accidental intelligence?
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Form by Karl Grammer
< 1 MIN READ
0
Desmond Morris Syndrome: No selective advantage
2 MIN READ
0
Fatal attractions: a fear of pheromones
2 MIN READ
0
Olfactory modulation of visual perception
2 MIN READ
0
Genetic Influences on Epigenetically Effected Disease
2 MIN READ
0
Why we love: Helen Fisher
< 1 MIN READ
0
Disorders of development: altered microRNA / messenger RNA balance
< 1 MIN READ
0
Eat like a monkey; act like a monkey
2 MIN READ
0
Do molecular mechanisms vary across species?
2 MIN READ
0
Creation vs Evolution: Expression of a newly found gene
2 MIN READ
0
Epistasis: Epigenetic effects of nutrient chemicals and their metabolism to pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Sex differences in Alzheimer's and everything else
2 MIN READ
0
Sex differences in Alzheimer’s and everything else
2 MIN READ
0
Are human pheromones chemosignals?
2 MIN READ
0
The Knowing Nose: Chemical Signals Communicate Human Emotions
< 1 MIN READ
0
The logic of gene regulatory networks
3 MIN READ
0
Creating new genes (and controlling diversity)
2 MIN READ
0
How Species Diversify
2 MIN READ
0
The same neural mechanisms are at work in worms and humans
2 MIN READ
0
Diet epigenetically effects development of the primate brain
< 1 MIN READ
0
A “new” form of natural selection?
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones determine our social behavior (REJECTED)
3 MIN READ
0
Pheromonemotionally speaking
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the fusiform fooled you area for face recognition
3 MIN READ
0
Embracing galaxy-wide, cellular, and brain complexity
2 MIN READ
0
“Just-So” stories vs scientific explanations
2 MIN READ
0
Adaptive evolution or not: cone receptors in the eye vs odor receptors
2 MIN READ
0
Insect to human cognition
2 MIN READ
0
Docosahexaenoic acid vs. creative use of mutations in natural selection
3 MIN READ
0
Mischaracterizations of adaptive evolution by psychologists and biologists
2 MIN READ
0
Did we descend from lottery winners (Part 2)
2 MIN READ
0
Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance of sexual orientation
2 MIN READ
0
Unconscious affects on incalculable genomic interactions
3 MIN READ
0
Natural selection: New insights are unlikely
< 1 MIN READ
0
Natural Selection and the Complexity of the Genome
2 MIN READ
0
ENCODE: extant vs extinct species and a clash of world views
4 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones: an epigenetic continuum from microbes to mammals
3 MIN READ
0
Biological facts constrain proponents of random mutations theory
2 MIN READ
0
Pheromones, Reciprocity, and Prosocial Behavior
3 MIN READ
0
Is the language of God the god problem? (1530 words)
6 MIN READ
0
Envisioning, hindsight bias, plagiarism, or cheating
3 MIN READ
0
The Epigenetics of Drug Development and Cholesterol Levels
< 1 MIN READ
0
Woefully ignorant politicians and popular science
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones, nutrition, DNA, epigenetics (2)
2 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects on the evolution of behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and diet-mediated life-extension
< 1 MIN READ
0
Copulins: Human pheromones effect physiology and affect social behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the definition of life
2 MIN READ
0
Chemical signaling may shed light on how the brain reacts to its environment
2 MIN READ
0
Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance via nutrient chemicals
1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and IQ via neurogenic and socio-cognitive niche construction
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: Diversity of signaling pathways and a common response
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones in business strategy
< 1 MIN READ
0
Is oxygen required for sensing nutrient chemicals and pheromones?
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones, social deprivation, and brain growth
< 1 MIN READ
0
Flies Evolve to Count (not)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and altruism
3 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and Multi-level selection
< 1 MIN READ
0
Nutrient mixture and memory in patients with early Alzheimer’s
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and inner conflict about evolution (1102 words)
4 MIN READ
0
A detailed model of physical reality and natural selection (722 words)
3 MIN READ
0
Hacking the Genome
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and Comparative Epigenomics
2 MIN READ
0
ecological social neurogenic niche
2 MIN READ
0
Bickering theorists: opinions about selfish genes and group selection
2 MIN READ
1
A nutrient chemical and pheromone-dependent neurogenic niche
2 MIN READ
0
Passing On Stress
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromone- and nutrient-dependent brain development and behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the visual appeal of other people (Part Three)
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the visual appeal of other people (Part Two)
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the visual appeal of other people (Part one)
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and brain development
2 MIN READ
0
Pre-existing genetic variability or random mutations: a matter of priorities and choices
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and Common Scents: Plants and Perfume
< 1 MIN READ
0
Adam’s rib: Pheromones and the adaptive evolution of human sexuality
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and your immune system
< 1 MIN READ
0
People select specific fragrances that suit their individual body odor
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: extremely technical representation of the concept
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: but No VNO; No Erox; No Human Pheromone Sciences
3 MIN READ
0
A fallacious leap? Ancestral and derived traits
3 MIN READ
0
Modeling odor processing in microbes, mice, and mankind
2 MIN READ
0
Love is a receptor-mediated event: the pervasive influence of the late Robert L. Moss
3 MIN READ
0
Exercise Alters Epigenetics
2 MIN READ
0
History of intelligence (550 words)
2 MIN READ
0
How could antibiotics alleviate symptoms of schizophrenia?
2 MIN READ
0
A Preoccupation With Modesty…
2 MIN READ
0
Explaining a good theory
< 1 MIN READ
0
Effects of pheromones on menstrual synchrony and a gay man
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: 2010 Powerpoint slides and 2011 poster presentation
2 MIN READ
0
Is Love in the Air? Human Pheromones and Axillary Chemistry by George Preti
3 MIN READ
0
Cookbook chemistry: food odors and hormones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and food odors
< 1 MIN READ
0
Another Remembered Present
2 MIN READ
0
Pheromones and food odors add more than just color to your world
4 MIN READ
0
Misrepresentations of biologically based cause and effect:
3 MIN READ
0
Timing is key in the proper wiring of the brain: study
2 MIN READ
0
Cause and effect in biology
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and sex differences in brain maturation
< 1 MIN READ
0
Show me the science!
5 MIN READ
0
Ethics, aphrodisiacs, and pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Digit ratio does not predict attractiveness of body odor
< 1 MIN READ
0
An organizing principle for our sense of smell
< 1 MIN READ
0
Epigenetics of food odors, nutrition, and pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromones and falling in love (circa 1974)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Trust the science. Don’t trust the hype
2 MIN READ
0
Men and women who stare at goats…
2 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects: Part III
3 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects (Part II)
3 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects
< 1 MIN READ
0
The epigenetics of food choice and mate choice
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromones and detectable odors
2 MIN READ
0
Avian ‘Axe effect’ attracts attention of females and males
2 MIN READ
0
Study results: Human pheromones affect women’s behavior
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and the Biology of Behavior
5 MIN READ
0
Honeybees, food odors, and perfume
< 1 MIN READ
0
Sniffing out your nightlife / Pheromone-infused nightclubs
< 1 MIN READ
0
Erox rises from the ashes
< 1 MIN READ
0
Avian recognition of human faces
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones Affect Women's Behavior
2 MIN READ
0
A lesser role for olfaction and pheromones in humans?
1 MIN READ
0
Creating a Myth
< 1 MIN READ
0
Dogs and humans: Then and now
< 1 MIN READ
0
Wikipedia comments by James V. Kohl
5 MIN READ
0
Excellent new book about pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and The Philosophy of Science
2 MIN READ
0
Natural scent of women linked to increased testosterone and seduction
< 1 MIN READ
0
Too many good-smelling males is not good
< 1 MIN READ
0
Debunking the myth of pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones in tears automagically effect testosterone
2 MIN READ
0
Exotic Pheromones and Concentrates
2 MIN READ
0
Mammalian pheromones are not a myth
3 MIN READ
0
Study Results: Human pheromones increase flirtatious behavior and ratings of attraction
2 MIN READ
0
Results: increased flirtatious behavior and self-reported attraction
2 MIN READ
0
Conditioned sexual arousal to odor
2 MIN READ
0
American and Canadian Mensa Presentation
< 1 MIN READ
0
Sold on the human VNO?
< 1 MIN READ
0
Another book author's comment on "The Great Pheromone Myth"
< 1 MIN READ
0
The Great Pheromone Myth (opinion/review)
19 MIN READ
0
Dr. Richard L. Doty's logic
2 MIN READ
2
Welcome to Pheromones.com
< 1 MIN READ
0
An attempt to change the concept
< 1 MIN READ
0
Scent of a woman: Men’s Testosterone Responses to Women's Scent
< 1 MIN READ
0
Earlier evidence: pheromones influence testosterone in men
< 1 MIN READ
0
[…] See also: Dialogue on pheromones: Avery Gilbert / James V. Kohl […]
[…] acid substitutions? In a series of 799 blog posts here that began on December 12, 2010 with: Dialogue on pheromones: Avery Gilbert / James V. Kohl, I have repeated reasserted the fact that nutrients metabolize to pheromones, which control the […]
[…] acid substitutions? In a series of 799 blog posts here that began on December 12, 2010 with: Dialogue on pheromones: Avery Gilbert / James V. Kohl, I have repeated reasserted the fact that nutrients metabolize to pheromones, which control the […]