Baiting the behaviorist(s)
A discussant on the International Society for Human Ethology (ISHE) group leveled a sarcastic attack on my credibility and my established level of expertise. See for example: Human pheromones: integrating neuroendocrinology and ethology. The attack, as most are, was devoid of any substantive content because it did not address cause and effect with regard to the visual response of the honeybee, which was the topic of discussion.
It is typically somewhat difficult for me to get others to realize they are not addressing cause and effect, but behaviorists are often the extremists in this regard. The problem is that some of them think their endless series of experiments will result in a better understanding of evolved human behavior. This problem led to the accusation that I was accusing all of psychology of the same kind of charlatanism.
My complaint is that many of the study results coming from behaviorists and other psychologists are relatively meaningless compared to those coming from molecular biologists and neuroscientists. But I’m not the only one who is complaining about psychologists with meaningless results. And both the FDA and the ASAM are now telling the clinical psychologists to pay attention to the neuroscientists when it comes to cause and effect.
The clinical psychologists will not be inclined to do so if the behaviorists and other pseudo/psycho-types do not quit telling their “stories” about cause and effect. Such stories, sans the gene-cell-tissue-organ-organ system pathway that I have detailed, are much like the “Just-so” stories of evolutionary psychology. In contrast the FDA Critical Path Initiative is clear (at least to me). These are the points of clarification I think are appropriate for discussion with behaviorists.
1. All demonstrations of contingencies of reinforcement that alter vertebrate behavior depend on activation by sensory stimuli of the gene, cell, tissue, organ, organ-system pathway that links reinforcement to behavior. Clearly, these are demonstrations of evolved behaviors.
2. Accurate interpretation of results from these demonstrations of evolved behaviors does not depend on any single level of analysis.
3. We cannot directly link any individual gene, cell, tissue, organ, or organ system to any behavior without including the rest of the pathway that links gene activation to brain-directed behavior.
3. Manipulations are not responsible for any brain-directed behavioral affect.
4. Manipulations appear to be causal to some effect when the lower levels of the Critical Path are ignored. (Wow, the stimulus did this to the animal’s behavior!)
5. Contextual ignorance incorporated into manipulations leads to meaningless results. (Wow, the brain did this to the animal’s behavior!)
6. Out of context results are not meaningful to anyone because they explain nothing.
7. Quantum physics is science that lies outside the context of the Critical Path; it explains nothing about evolved behavior.
Point number 7 is made because dumbfounded discussants typically bring physics to bear and attempt to use it as an “out” of discussions of things they don’t understand. I take this as an admission of their embarrassment when they realize they cannot continue discussion of biologically based effects on hormones, and especially their affect on behavior in the context of a topic linking visual input to behavior. It’s tough to link visual input as the cause of any behavior in any insect species.
The discussion of cause and effect required in the context of the Critical Path adds the a neuroscientific perspective, which is why the 2011 ASAM policy clearly states that: “Current neuroscience recognizes that the neurocircuitry of reward also involves a rich bi-directional circuitry…” and it addresses the need for a comprehensive biological, psychological, social and spiritual assessment by a trained and certified professional.
For contrast, medical practitioners do not require anything from behaviorists who have been trained to assess only the manipulated behavior of species that can be conditioned to press levers, peck at keys, peck at colored dots, jump through hoops, or whatever. As an added diversionary tactic, the discussant brought in the equally irrelevant mention of philosophy. And, in an era where the molecular biology of cause, effect on hormones, and affect on behavior is used to explain evolved behaviors, I’m not sure what Aristotle’s 4 kinds of “cause” have to do with anything. (He’s still dead, right?) So is discussion of cause and effect on the International Society for Human Ethology (ISHE) group.
Want more on the same topic?
Swipe/Drag Left and Right To Browse Related Posts:
The physics of existence (8)
2 MIN READ
0
Natural selection for adaptation (7)
2 MIN READ
0
Pheromones protect us from viruses (5)
3 MIN READ
0
MicroRNAs on Veteran’s Day 2019
< 1 MIN READ
0
#SFN2019 to 2012: Hiding the facts (2)
6 MIN READ
0
Multigenerational epigenetic inheritance (3)
3 MIN READ
0
Patented Creation vs Evolution of Disease (5)
3 MIN READ
0
The tipping point (revisited): Koch postulates
4 MIN READ
0
Light-activated continuous environmental tracking (1)
5 MIN READ
0
Two photon-linked biodiversity (2)
2 MIN READ
0
The ‘confusant’ hypothesis
4 MIN READ
0
Michael Bloomberg for President (NOT) in 2020
2 MIN READ
0
The eternal significance of microRNAs (1)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Sympatric Speciation vs pseudosceintific nonsense (4)
2 MIN READ
0
Laws of Biology / Rules of Life
3 MIN READ
0
Polymaths and paradigm shifts: from Asimov to Bear (4)
6 MIN READ
0
MicroRNAs biophysically constrain behavior
4 MIN READ
0
Creating biophysically constrained viral latency (2)
2 MIN READ
0
From base editing to RNA editing (6)
8 MIN READ
0
Darwinian adaptation: a clear evolutionary trail?
4 MIN READ
0
Trashing the 2nd Law
7 MIN READ
0
A null mutation and healthy longevity?
4 MIN READ
0
Eating electrons and excreting degraded energy
3 MIN READ
0
Natural selection for racism and all pathology
6 MIN READ
0
Until death: Virus-driven failure of multisensory integration (2)
6 MIN READ
0
Dispelling the ignorance of theorists
4 MIN READ
0
Neurosteroids revisited two decades later
3 MIN READ
0
God vs host-derived creation of virus-driven pathology
6 MIN READ
0
Francis S. Collins refutes theistic evolution
6 MIN READ
0
Twisted theories and weaponized facts
3 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent alternative splicings 1996 – 2016
12 MIN READ
0
Dietary lutein and pheromone-controlled brain development
4 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent self-organization and self repair
8 MIN READ
0
From precis to pre-mRNA and proof of concept in F1, F2, F3
6 MIN READ
0
Demoncrats fight polycombic ecological adaptation
4 MIN READ
0
Biological evolution as a philosophy, not a science
6 MIN READ
0
Did evolution autophosphorylate your kinases? (2)
5 MIN READ
1
Asking the right questions (1)
3 MIN READ
0
Conserved biophotonic emissions
7 MIN READ
2
Antithetical conclusions (4)
3 MIN READ
0
Biophysically constrained cell type differentiation
3 MIN READ
0
Biophotonics, glycobiology, quantized biodiversity (2)
19 MIN READ
0
Biophotonics, glycobiology, quantized biodiversity
4 MIN READ
0
Major transition ends use of silly theories
5 MIN READ
0
Cracking the Olfactory Code?
5 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent RNA methylation (6)
9 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent RNA methylation (3)
10 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent RNA methylation (2)
5 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent biodiversity (2)
2 MIN READ
0
Energy-dependent biodiversity
5 MIN READ
0
The tipping point? 50, 000 publications (2)
2 MIN READ
0
Energy dependent RNA-mediated immunity (2)
10 MIN READ
0
Science vs semantics
4 MIN READ
0
Cytogenetic approaches link biosystems to ecosystems
3 MIN READ
0
Center stage RNA-mediated events (since 1996)
3 MIN READ
0
Juvenile hormone links atoms to ecosystems
3 MIN READ
0
Teleophobes vs teleophiles: a recent history
2 MIN READ
0
Genes, orchid odors, and pheromones from blonds
5 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated theory killers (11) (12) (13) (14) (15)
7 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic (re)programming of behavior (3)
5 MIN READ
0
Assumptions prove ignorance
5 MIN READ
0
Cell type differentiation: atoms to ecosystems
2 MIN READ
0
Models are not theories (1)
2 MIN READ
0
Mechanisms of stress: from genes to cancer
9 MIN READ
0
Multi-omic analysis features (SNPs, miRNA)
3 MIN READ
0
Hematopoiesis and practopoiesis
4 MIN READ
0
The pseudoscientific nonsense of behaviorists
< 1 MIN READ
0
“New” epigenetic mechanism for lifelong learning?
3 MIN READ
0
Unconscious affect (revisited)
2 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated cell type differentiation: Honeybee
< 1 MIN READ
0
“First” evidence
5 MIN READ
0
Hypotheses and mathematical philosophy
3 MIN READ
0
Pattern recognition: biogeochemical structure and function
5 MIN READ
0
Appetite for ingesting theories (raw)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Batch effect vs epigenetic effects
3 MIN READ
0
Gene expression, immortality, and cancer
6 MIN READ
0
Bees and primates automagically evolve
3 MIN READ
0
A special issue on nutritional epigenetics
5 MIN READ
0
Retinoic acid + one receptor regulate the genome
3 MIN READ
0
MicroRNAs and the exposome
5 MIN READ
0
Effect and affect of a single base-pair change
4 MIN READ
0
MicroRNAs and memory
< 1 MIN READ
0
RNA-directed gene choice
5 MIN READ
0
Walk towards the light
< 1 MIN READ
0
Rejecting what is known about viral microRNAs and nutrient-dependent microRNAs
2 MIN READ
0
Imagining that data historically supports evolutionary theory
7 MIN READ
0
An epigenetic trap (the sequel)
10 MIN READ
0
Chemical ecology and RNA-mediated control of DNA loops
< 1 MIN READ
0
One test of bioenergetic health?
2 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic pharmacology and RNA-mediated transciptional landscapes
3 MIN READ
0
RNA-mediated events and "The Theory of Everything"
4 MIN READ
0
Thermodynamic constraints and ecological adaptations sans evolution
6 MIN READ
0
Eliminating correlations from evolutionary ecology
6 MIN READ
0
Pharmacogenomics
3 MIN READ
0
A model of MHC 'evolution'
2 MIN READ
0
From deep time into real time: What evolutionary processes?
10 MIN READ
0
ALPHA GENOMIX
7 MIN READ
2
Eliminating evolutionary theory
3 MIN READ
0
2014 and 2004 Nobel Prize in Medicine
3 MIN READ
0
Color vision refutes the evolutionary dogma of gene duplication
4 MIN READ
0
Systems biology and memory disorders
3 MIN READ
0
Physics, Chemistry, and Molecular biology (PCMb)
2 MIN READ
0
Ecological variation and niche construction: 1, 2, 3
6 MIN READ
0
Epigenetically-effected metabolic shifts and ecological adaptations
3 MIN READ
0
Did our adapted mind evolve? (Revisited)
2 MIN READ
0
De novo gene Creation sans evolution of genes via mutations
4 MIN READ
0
Did our adapted mind evolve?
6 MIN READ
0
RNA-directed DNA methylation and RNA-mediated events
5 MIN READ
1
Probable changes in connectivity
2 MIN READ
0
Watching and waiting for more retractions
2 MIN READ
0
Behavior (3): All responses are RNA-mediated in bees
3 MIN READ
0
Behavior (2): All responses are RNA-mediated not genetically-determined
4 MIN READ
0
Evolutionary heritage or ecological adaptation? Racism versus reality
4 MIN READ
0
Insect homology and diversity attributed to mutations
2 MIN READ
0
A microRNA-mediated mechanism that is epigenetically inherited
2 MIN READ
0
Ecologically linked adapted ants and brains
2 MIN READ
0
Nutrient-dependent cooperation vs cannibalism (video)
2 MIN READ
0
Another powerful refutation of mutation-initiated natural selection
4 MIN READ
0
The wrong picture of our evolution
4 MIN READ
0
Targeting a cancer gene
2 MIN READ
0
Social experiences epigenetically effect gene networks
2 MIN READ
0
Functional coding variants are not mutations
2 MIN READ
0
Hormones effect sensitivity to androsterone
2 MIN READ
0
Evolved development of olfactory systems
2 MIN READ
0
Non-random evolution of a “molecular handshake”
2 MIN READ
0
Adaptive evolution: Genetic selection against some disorders
3 MIN READ
0
Music to our ears and song in birds: a common sense approach
2 MIN READ
0
A mathematical model of phenotypic cause, effects on genes, and affects on behavior
2 MIN READ
0
A newly discovered hypothalamic neurogenic niche in the brain
< 1 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects underlie sexual preferences II
3 MIN READ
0
Fish Odor Syndrome
< 1 MIN READ
0
Is there a model for that?
3 MIN READ
0
Pheromone-induced learning: a NEW model?
2 MIN READ
0
The challenges of a Darwinian approach to anything
3 MIN READ
0
Mutated genes and accidental intelligence?
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Form by Karl Grammer
< 1 MIN READ
0
Never too young to learn WHAT?
< 1 MIN READ
0
Fatal attractions: a fear of pheromones
2 MIN READ
0
Olfactory modulation of visual perception
2 MIN READ
0
Consequences and Evolution: The Cause That Works Backwards
4 MIN READ
0
Eat like a monkey; act like a monkey
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: Epigenetic Effects on Hormones and Their Affects on Behavior
3 MIN READ
0
Are human pheromones chemosignals?
2 MIN READ
0
The Knowing Nose: Chemical Signals Communicate Human Emotions
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: Epigenetic Effects of Odors and Their Affects on Behavior
2 MIN READ
0
The same neural mechanisms are at work in worms and humans
2 MIN READ
0
Pheromonemotionally speaking
2 MIN READ
0
Nobel laureate challenges psychologists to clean up their act
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the fusiform fooled you area for face recognition
3 MIN READ
0
Playing with breasts (e.g, with a new THEORY of why only heterosexual men love them)
3 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects on stochastic gene expression and evolutionary psychology
2 MIN READ
0
Genetic test predicts autism risk
< 1 MIN READ
0
Chemical conditioning of food reward and drug addiction
< 1 MIN READ
0
Insect to human cognition
2 MIN READ
0
What to do with research results: Warning!
2 MIN READ
0
Mischaracterizations of adaptive evolution by psychologists and biologists
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the epigenetic effects of isolation
2 MIN READ
0
Unconscious affects on incalculable genomic interactions
3 MIN READ
0
Natural selection and the behavior of whole organisms
< 1 MIN READ
0
Is the language of God the god problem? (1530 words)
6 MIN READ
0
Woefully ignorant politicians and popular science (2)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Epigenetic effects on the evolution of behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Copulins: Human pheromones effect physiology and affect social behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Children’s healthy diets lead to healthier IQ
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromones and the phylogeny of operant and classical conditioning
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones from the bottom-up and top-down
3 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: Diversity of signaling pathways and a common response (Part 2)
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones: Diversity of signaling pathways and a common response
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones are like sugar (and spice)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Is Science Metaphysically Neutral About Free Will?
2 MIN READ
0
Oxytocin for everything?
2 MIN READ
1
A neuroscientific perspective on neurobiological differences in everyone
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and Multi-level selection
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and inner conflict about evolution (1102 words)
4 MIN READ
0
Receptor-mediated biological cause and effect
2 MIN READ
0
Where is the love?
3 MIN READ
0
Is modeling natural selection as a sensing agent reasonable?
3 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones: Olfaction, odor receptors, learning, memory, mood, brains and behavior
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromone- and nutrient-dependent brain development and behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the visual appeal of other people (Part Three)
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and the visual appeal of other people (Part one)
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones and brain development
2 MIN READ
0
Pre-existing genetic variability or random mutations: a matter of priorities and choices
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and Common Scents: Plants and Perfume
< 1 MIN READ
0
No fooling; visual appeal is not determined by what we see
2 MIN READ
0
A fear of pheromones (revisited)
3 MIN READ
0
A fallacious leap? Ancestral and derived traits
3 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones in Socioaffective Neuroscience & Psychology
2 MIN READ
0
They are what they eat, and so are we
2 MIN READ
0
History of intelligence (550 words)
2 MIN READ
0
A Preoccupation With Modesty…
2 MIN READ
0
The biology of behavior: Seeing more clearly
< 1 MIN READ
0
Genes not culture drive humans forward (an antithetical approach)
< 1 MIN READ
0
Teaching science to the religious: theories of development
2 MIN READ
0
Do Pheromones Play a Role in Our Sex Lives: Scientific American
< 1 MIN READ
0
Epigenetics and the connectome
2 MIN READ
0
Pheromones and food odors add more than just color to your world
4 MIN READ
0
The Perversion of Science by Evolutionary Psychologists
5 MIN READ
0
Human skull study causes evolutionary headache
< 1 MIN READ
0
Docosahexaenoic acid and autism: praying for hope, or preying on hope
< 1 MIN READ
0
Timing is key in the proper wiring of the brain: study
2 MIN READ
0
Behavioral epigenetics
2 MIN READ
0
Baiting evolutionary psychologists and others who damn religion
3 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones may influence brain chemistry into adulthood
< 1 MIN READ
0
Show me the science!
5 MIN READ
0
Theory versus biological facts: Mental modules and models for behavior
2 MIN READ
0
“Genes (are not) Activated by Sound!”
3 MIN READ
0
An organizing principle for our sense of smell
< 1 MIN READ
0
Men and women who stare at goats…
2 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects: Part III
3 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects (Part II)
3 MIN READ
0
The Sex Lives of Insects
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromone-enhanced behavior in sexually inexperienced females
2 MIN READ
0
The “yuck” factor: aversion to social odors?
2 MIN READ
0
The Mind’s Eyes: Mindful modeling of brain directed behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Study results: Human pheromones affect women’s behavior
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and the Biology of Behavior
5 MIN READ
0
Honeybees, food odors, and perfume
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones Affect Women's Behavior
2 MIN READ
0
A lesser role for olfaction and pheromones in humans?
1 MIN READ
0
Study results: Human pheromones influence human behavior
2 MIN READ
0
The great pheromone myth revisited (including biological factors in the development of sexuality)
4 MIN READ
0
The great pheromone myth revisited (including biological factors in the development of sexuality)
4 MIN READ
0
Wikipedia comments by James V. Kohl
5 MIN READ
0
For ethologists: Observation does not trump molecular biology
2 MIN READ
0
Human Pheromones and The Philosophy of Science
2 MIN READ
0
Genes, Hormones, and Behavior (for other scientists)
4 MIN READ
0
A fundamental attribution error: Love at first sight
3 MIN READ
0
Biofiction, Philosophy, Pheromones, and Spirituality
2 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones in tears automagically effect testosterone
2 MIN READ
0
Tears and fears of pheromones
2 MIN READ
0
Exotic Pheromones and Concentrates
2 MIN READ
0
Study Results: Human pheromones increase flirtatious behavior and ratings of attraction
2 MIN READ
0
Results: increased flirtatious behavior and self-reported attraction
2 MIN READ
0
Is it what he or she sees in you, or is it your pheromones?
2 MIN READ
0
Conditioning of the human pair bond by human pheromones
< 1 MIN READ
0
Human pheromones work by effecting hormones that affect behavior
2 MIN READ
0
Conditioned sexual arousal to odor
2 MIN READ
0
Presentation on Human Pheromones delivered on August 3, 2010
2 MIN READ
0
American and Canadian Mensa Presentation
< 1 MIN READ
0
Pheromones of pregnant women effect prolactin in men
< 1 MIN READ
0
The Great Pheromone Myth (opinion/review)
19 MIN READ
0
Scent of a woman: Men’s Testosterone Responses to Women's Scent
< 1 MIN READ
0
Luteinizing hormone, sex, and smell (18 years later)
2 MIN READ
0